An agroforestry garden in Southeast Sulawesi, Indonesia
Although Indonesia has become synonymous with tropical deforestation in recent decades, an alternative model of rural development is possible that both protects biodiversity while improving the welfare of rural Indonesians. Diversified agroforestry systems, which have traditionally dominated Indonesian farming for hundreds, if not thousands of years, could form the basis for conserving biodiversity while restoring degraded landscapes. Farmers and indigenous communities, however, need incentives to maintain and expand the cultivation of these diversified farming systems such as market access and better price for their commodities. Inobu aims to make the case for Fakfak nutmeg farming communities so that they can access premium markets to incentivise their current farming systems.
Swidden fields as part of an agroforestry system in Southeast Sulawesi, Indonesia
Indonesian farmers, throughout history, have relied on diverse farming systems for the livelihoods and lives. The forest gardens or kebun have typically encompassed complex and biologically diverse systems of forests, swidden fallows, and mixtures of subsistence crops and cash crops, such as spices and rubber. These smallholders, especially indigenous farmers, and their farming systems, protect biodiversity, sequester carbon and provide other ecosystem services such as regulating water.
In recent decades, however, the Indonesian archipelago, stretching across multiple bio-geographic regions, has experienced massive transformations. Driven by industrial-scale land uses, supported by government policies, biologically diverse landscapes have been degraded and transformed into expanses of monocultures of forest and plantation commodities.
Rural communities have been presented with few alternative pathways for farming. In many instances, farmers have lost their lands through land grabbing or forced acquisitions through government schemes. Other farmers have chosen to participate formally in plantation schemes. Those that have chosen to remain independent have either continued traditional farming systems, or converted part or all of their lands to monocultures, such as oil palm.
The ecological and economic limits of this transition are beginning to emerge. In parts of Indonesia, plantations have caused catastrophic floods. Degradation has driven further degradation, as exposed peatland and degraded forests have burned during prolonged droughts and dry spells. In response, strict bans on burning in other places has meant that farmers have had to convert to monocultures, continue to farm illegally or face hardship.
Is another path possible for Indonesian farmers?
Historically, the Indonesian policy and regulatory framework has focused on supporting farmers through schemes with companies. The institutional infrastructure for supporting independent smallholders in Indonesia to farm productively and sustainably is largely missing. Independent farmers have limited or no formal access to land and resources, limited access to training, technical knowledge, inputs and technology either through government or private sector.
A new model of development is needed that enables these farmers to maintain their diverse forest garden systems and formalise their rights to land and resources while improving the profitability of farming for rural communities.
A nutmeg agroforest in Fakfak, Papua Barat
In Papua Barat, Inobu, working with the local indigenous organisation AKAPe and the local government, has been exploring a model of developing the production of Papuan nutmeg that benefits local communities while protecting the vast forests of Fakfak district. The challenges facing Papuan nutmeg farmers are the same challenges facing farmers across Indonesia, however, there are opportunities. New policy and regulatory instruments for recognising the rights of customary communities, financial instruments and increased demand for sustainably produced products means that a viable model is within reach. There is demand for sustainably and inclusively produced products both within Indonesia as well as global markets. Farmers and local communities, however, need assistance to improve the quality and volume of their produce to meet these demands, as well as support for processing raw products into higher value products that can be sold to consumers.
As part of the agroforestry system in Fakfak, subsistence crops are grown in areas adjacent to nutmeg forests and forest ecosystems
Our ongoing challenge in Papua Barat, and more broadly in Indonesia, is making these instruments work on the ground for the benefit of nature and society. From the lessons learned from these pilot initiatives, we can help to inform the government on how to improve the policy and regulatory environment to support independent smallholders and indigenous communities to farm sustainably and productively.
In Indonesia, 40 million small-scale farmers produce one third of the nation’s palm oil and up to 100% of other agricultural export commodities. Most of these farmers are “invisible” — they are not registered by the government and can therefore not take advantage of governmental programs.
The e-STDB was developed to address these challenges. It evolved out of a collaborative initiative in the province of Central Kalimantan to map and register all oil palm smallholders in three districts, Seruyan, Kotawaringin Barat and Gunung Mas, and issue them with cultivation registration letters.
The e-STDB system provides local governments with a simplified database of farmers’ plots, socio-economic data, and registrations. From this information, the STDB can be issued electronically, where farmers can apply directly for a STDB through a dedicated website or via their village heads. The system is integrated with an Android surveying and mapping application that has already been tested in Central Kalimantan and West Papua. The e-STDB will also consolidate data from other initiatives and organizations into a centralized database hosted by the Ministry of Agriculture.
The system will incorporate data for 126 commodities produced by small-scale farmers, ranging from coconut and palm oil to patchouli and pepper. The e-STDB is a key instrument facilitating the inclusion of small-scale producers in to legal and sustainable supply chains. It will also support the Ministry of Agriculture in providing better targeted extension services to small-scale commodity producers across Indonesia.
E-STDB was the result of over four years of collaboration between Yayasan Penelitian Inovasi Bumi (INOBU), Earth Innovation Institute, and provincial and district governments in Central Kalimantan and West Papua.